P & E Steak House

Love this place! The stuffed Mushrooms, Duck Wontons and Smoked Salmon were Amazing! Everything we have had here is always cooked to perfection. If you haven't been here you definitely need to! Update..Just stopped here again and gotta say the Lobster and Pork Chop are so Amazing! The best I have ever had! You also have to try Randy's House Oscar!! So good!!

Small in size but not in flavor. Wanted a Friday fish fry and they did not disappoint. You get soup, salad and choice of potato for a VERY reasonable price. Would recommend if you want a great meal.

An excellent Supper Club experience. Ribeye & Pork tenderloin were delicious. Some of the same great staff and a few new ones.

Very friendly and attentive server. Meal included soup, salad, relish tray, crackers, and dinner rolls. Nice variety of desserts also. Dining room is small. Reservations are recommended. Food was average.

Really enjoyed the ease of making a reservation. Food and service were amazing. Loved the little relish tray and everything tasted like someone really cooked with care. I had ribs my friends had salmon and smothered chicken. So good. Will be back.

A Hidden Supper Club Gem If you're looking for a true Wisconsin supper club experience, P&E Steak House delivers in every way. From the moment we walked in, the clean and welcoming atmosphere set the tone for an exceptional evening. The staff were warm, attentive, and genuinely made us feel like part of the family. This wasn’t just dinner—it was a multi-course culinary journey. We started with a tray of fresh veggies and fruit, accompanied by liver spread, coleslaw, and a veggie spread that was surprisingly flavorful. Then came the appetizers: warm, fresh bread, crisp salad, and a comforting bowl of soup. The main course was hearty and satisfying, and dessert was the perfect sweet ending. Portions were more then generous, and the prices more than fair—especially considering the quality and quantity of food. You leave full, happy, and already planning your next visit. The only bittersweet note was spotting a “For Sale” sign outside. Just as we discovered this gem, it might be changing hands. We truly hope it stays just the way it is for a while longer. P&E Steak House isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a supper club experience done right. We’ll definitely be back.

The staff is so awesome they were amazing! The food was also really good. They are clever with some items making it easy to get for low staff. The only thing is they have limited seating, so be sure to call and make a reservation or you most likely won’t get a table.

We had two every large groups but we still had excellent service and the food came out timely. I had the scallops and my friend had the steak they were cooked and seasoned to perfection.